The smell, sound, and feel of a baseball mitt are all part of the mystique of the game, as described in depth by the Seattle Times. Pro players have habits, rituals, downright superstitions with their gloves. Some use the same glove for years, developing a close bond with the well-worn leather. Others have a regular replacement schedule, with game performance sometimes playing a part. For those with a long-term relationship, there are glove repair specialists. Fran Fleet, who particularly enjoys the dog chewing repair work, has her own recommendations for breaking in and caring for your glove.